Select by gender or name

Car Crash Leads To Murder

On November 26th, 2004, Lance Collin Shockley and Jeffrey Bayless went out in Bayless’s truck. On their way back home, Shockley was driving and crashed into a ditch.

He went to a nearby home and told the home’s owners, Ivy and Paul Napier. He had crashed nearby, and his friend was hurt. Paul went to the accident scene along with Shockly, but Bayless was dead.

Paul and Shockley returned to the Napier home, and Shockley called his wife. She eventually picked him up, and he told her and Bayless’s fiancée that he was dead.

Ivy contacted the police at some point, and when they arrived at the scene, they noticed beer cans and a tequila bottle in the car.

During the investigation, Shockley denied involvement and the Napiers didn’t point the finger at him. Shockley’s wife and Bayless’s fiancée also kept their mouth shut about his involvement.

Four months later, Highway Patrol Sergeant Carl Graham Jr. visited Ivy at her workplace. He tricked her into confessing that Shockley was driving the car the day of the crash.

When Shockley learned what the sheriff had done, he was enraged. He borrowed his grandmother’s Pontiac Grand Am, which had a bright yellow sticker on the back.

He patrolled Graham’s neighborhood on March 20th, 2005, and parked several blocks away. When Graham pulled up at 4:03 pm and got out of his car, he was shot multiple times, leaving him dead.

He was found around 5:15 pm, and within hours, Shockley was identified as the prime suspect.

Investigation into Shockley

Authorities attempted to question him, but he denied involvement, claimed he had an alibi, and then threw them off his property.

They approached him at his job the next day. He elaborated on his alibi, saying he spent time with relatives and his neighbor. He also said he didn’t know where Graham lived.

Shockley was arrested on March 23rd, 2005, for leaving the scene of the November accident that left Bayless dead.

Six days later, he was charged with first-degree murder and armed criminal action in the death of Sergeant Graham.

Legal Proceedings

According to CBS News, when he went to trial, prosecutors said he killed Sergeant Graham to stop the investigation into Bayless’s death.

Shockley’s attorney claimed his client was only being prosecuted because police were too focused on Shockley and didn’t pursue other leads. They felt the case against him was highly circumstantial.

The jury sided with the prosecution and convicted Shockley of first-degree murder. During the sentencing phase of the trial, the jury could not agree on a life in prison sentence or a death sentence. This deadlock put the decision in the hands of the judge, and he sentenced Shockley to death.

He was sentenced to death.

Fight to get off death row

According to CBS News, Shockley spent years appealing his sentence, saying that he didn’t receive a fair trial or sentencing, but the appeals went nowhere. His attorneys also fought for 16 pieces of evidence to be tested for DNA. They felt that evidence would reveal who the real killer was, but the motion was denied.

On June 14th, 2025, the Missouri Supreme Court issued a warrant of execution, scheduling Shockley’s execution for October 14th, 2025, the Missouri Independent reported.

Survey results released on October 3rd, 2025, showed that 79% of Democrats and 53% of Republicans supported clemency. 440 people had completed the survey. Some survey participants didn’t think the evidence was strong enough to support a death sentence.

Others didn’t like that the jury couldn’t agree on a sentence, leaving the death sentence decision up to the judge. Some also felt his good behavior behind bars, including saving another inmate’s life, entitled him to live another day.

Ultimately, the clemency decision was in the Governor’s hands, and he announced in a press release on October 13th, 2025, that Shockley’s clemency request was denied. He called Shockley’s crime “an attack not only on a dedicated law enforcement officer, but on the rule of law itself.”

He also said, “Carrying out Lance Shockley’s sentence is evidence of our commitment to the pursuit of justice”

Execution

According to APNews, Shocklet visited with his daughters and one of his friends on the morning of his execution day. At some point, he had a last meal of peanut butter, three packs of oatmeal, water, and two sports drinks, basically a bunch of snacks from the canteen.

When his execution started at around 6 p.m., 32 people were watching, seven people were there for Shockley, 12 were there for Graham, and the final 13 were there for the state.

His final statement was a written one which ended with, “So also you have sorrow now, but I will see you again, and your hearts will rejoice, and no one will take your joy from you.” It’s unclear if this statement was read before the execution or just released to the media after his death.

After being injected with a lethal dose of drugs, he was pronounced dead at 6:13 pm.