Select by gender or name

Murder of James Orr

According to Findlaw, James Orr had an injury as a child that left him disabled and confined to a wheelchair. His disability didn’t stop him from finding love. He married Rhonda in 1999, but they didn’t live happily ever after. Rhonda was unfaithful, and four years later, she was pregnant with another man’s baby, and she and James were divorcing. James was planning to move to a new apartment on May 17th, 2003. One friend would later say that James was excited to be getting a free start. Sadly, he died before he could start his new life.

In the early hours of May 14th, 2003, the Orr home caught on fire. Rhonda and her daughter, Amanda, had escaped the house and were standing on the curb along with their neighbors when Officer William Miller showed up. Rhoda quickly approached them, pointed to the burning house, and told them that James was still inside.

She claimed that as the home was going up in flames, she tried to wheel him out, but he kicked her away the shut and locked himself in the back bedroom. She was forced to escape without him. She and Officer Miller went to the front of the house, and she gave him directions to the master bedroom. Officer Miller went into the residence while Rhonda waited outside.

Officer Miller called James’ name multiple times, but there was no response. He kicked in the door to the master bedroom. Once inside, he saw a wheelchair, but not James. Officer Miller retreated outside and spoke to Rhonda again. She insisted her husband was in the master bedroom. Officer Miller put his life on the line two more times, but he couldn’t locate James in the master bedroom.

Officer Miller began to struggle breathing due to the fire and smoke, and parts of the ceiling collapsed. For his own safety, he had to abandon the home. Once he returned outside, Officer Robert Walton had arrived. They wanted to see if they could enter the home another way. They went to the back and kicked in a window to the master bedroom, but the flames were too much.

The mission failed, and once firefighters arrived, Miller returned to the front of the home and apologized for letting her down. He was taken to a hospital to have his injuries treated. James was later found inside the master bedroom’s bathroom, near the toilet. Resuscitation efforts failed, and he died from smoke inhalation and burns over 80% of his body. Miller was unaware that the room had a bathroom, and he felt that he could have found James if he had known.

Based on Rhonda’s demeanor at the scene, police and firefighters thought she was a worried spouse. She didn’t care about getting treatment for smoke inhalation and only wanted them to rescue James.

Rhonda’s Story

According to Findlaw, Rhonda was interviewed the next day at 9:30 a.m., and she told investigators that the night before, James was bragging about being drunk. She also claimed he was taking Flexeril, which, according to Drugs.com, is a muscle relaxant.

She said there was a fire earlier that night that had to be put out. She claimed to have seen a tipped-over candle, a tipped-over bottle of alcohol, and a clock radio hanging by its cord. She tried to imply that James was drunk and reckless, causing the first fire. She wanted detectives to believe that James also caused the second fire.

She said the smoke alarm woke her up, and she escaped with Amanda. She dropped Amanda off at the neighbor’s, Robert and his wife, Lindsey. Rhonda claimed she returned to her home alone, went back inside, and tried to save James. That’s when he struggled with her and kicked her away before shutting and locking the door.

She said that when she couldn’t get the door open, she returned to the neighbor’s and asked Robert to come back to the home with her.

Neighbors and Rhonda’s Refute Rhonda’s Story

When Robert and Lindsey, were interviewed, Rhonda’s story fell apart. They told detectives that Rhonda was banging on their door at around 3:30 or 3:45 am, and when they opened the door, Rhonda was with Amanda and told her neighbors that her home was on fire and James was still inside. Lindsey said she called 911 to report the fire after she learned that Rhonda hadn’t done so.

Rhonda left Amanda with Lindsey while she and Robert went back to the home. Robert heard smoke detectors and saw the entryway full of smoke. Despite the danger, he and Rhonda entered the home, went to the master bedroom door, and tried to open it, but it was locked.

They heard James groaning like he was in pain. Feeling unsafe, they soon went back outside and waited for first responders. Robert made it clear that Rhonda never had the chance to enter the home alone, meaning her tale of her trying to save her husband before he kicked her aside and locked the door was a lie.

Detectives also learned that Rhonda didn’t want them to know she was pregnant, and at one point, she asked Lindsey to say she was the one who was pregnant.

Amanda told police that after she and her mother escaped the fire, her mother went back in by herself for about 20 seconds before coming back out and taking her to the neighbors.

Detectives find the motive

As the investigation progressed, authorities determined that Farmer’s insurance would pay $176,000 plus an additional $108,000 for personal items. James also had a life insurance policy that paid $250,000. On top of that, there were two Cigna life insurance policies worth a total of $150,000, a Monumental life insurance policy with a $225,000, a CUNA accidental death policy that paid $100,000, and a $200,000 policy with Fidelity and Guaranty Life Insurance.

She was the beneficiary of all the policies and was looking at a potential $1.209 million in payouts after the loss of her home property and husband. Detectives also learned that she contacted many of the insurance companies the same day that James died.

Additional Evidence Points To Rhonda

An autopsy revealed that James didn’t have alcohol or Flexeril in system. On top of that, the lack of soot on Rhonda’s mouth and nose at the time of the fire raised suspicions. A fire investigator with decades of experience didn’t think the fire was accidental. He observed multiple points of origin in the master bedroom and ruled the fire to be arson.

Arrest and Conviction

Rhonda probably thought she got away with it after some time passed, but in February 2004, police came knocking with an arrest warrant. When she went to trial in March 2008, the prosecutors portrayed her as black widow who wanted her husband dead, so she could pocket more than $1 million and start a new life with her boyfriend.

The defense fought back, saying that the separation was amicable and she had no motive to kill James as he had promised to give her the profits from its eventual sale.

The jury sided with prosecutors and convicted her of first-degree arson resulting in death. Days later, on April 1st, 2008, she returned to court for sentencing. The prosecution asked the jury to give her a life sentence. Her lawyers, on the other hand, asked for probation. They said she was a mother of two with no prior felony convictions.

The jury handed down an 88-year sentence. That seems like a lot until you realize that she only had to serve 15 years or less before being eligible for release.

Parole

She became eligible for parole on May 5th, 2014, but she has not been successful in gaining her release. At her last parole hearing in November 2023, she was denied because of the violent nature of her offense and because the parole board deemed her “a continuing threat to public safety.”

As of October 11th, 2026, she is in the parole review process and will learn whether the 53-year-old will walk free or remain locked up for several more years. If she is granted parole, she will likely be back on the streets before Thanksgiving.